Alpha Adrenergic Receptor Agonist (Alpha Agonist)
Brimonidine
Brimonidine is now available in two forms: Alphagan 0.2% ophthalmic
solution and Alphagan-P 0.15% ophthalmic solution. Very simply,
Allergan has replaced the BAK preservative with a much less
toxic proprietary preservative, Purite. This is the same non-toxic
preservative that is used in their Refresh Tears artificial
tear. The 0.15% solution is equally effective to the 0.2% traditional
solution.
| Two Types of Brimonidine |
|
Generic Brimonidine
|
Alphagan P
|
| 0.2% brimonidine |
0.15% brimonidine |
| BAK 0.05% |
Purite 0.005% |
| pH 6.3-6.5 |
pH 6.6-7.4 |
| vehicle PVA |
vehicle CMC |
| AE: 10-30% |
AE: 10-20% |
Generic brimonidine is markedly less expensive than Alphagan-P,
and performs equally as well. The FDA made the following
key conclusions:
- "The risk/benefit ratio of AlphaganR vs AlphaganR
P is essentially the same"
- "The differences in adverse events and IOP lowering
ability are not clinically significant"
- "We find any differences in study results between
the two products to be typical of the variability seen in
clinical trials and do not find the difference in this case
to be clinically significant"
Brimonidine is approved for tid therapy. There is some debate
on whether tid or bid dosing is better. While tid administration
will give maximum and more uniform IOP reduction, most studies
have found that bid administration will adequately reduce IOP
in most patients. Because of a distinct “trough” effect at
about eight hours, we do dose brimonidine tid when using this
drug as monotherapy; however, its use for monotherapy is rarely
employed.
We tell the patient to instill the first drop within the first
hour upon awakening, and the second drop near bedtime. This
does leave a relative gap in coverage in the afternoon hours
(when IOP is generally physiologically lower anyway), but hopefully
keeps enough drug on-board to suppress the common surge in
IOP during the early morning (pre-waking) hours.
We occasionally recommend three minutes of gentle eyelid closure
to maximize ocular absorption and effectiveness, and minimize
systemic absorption. (We employ this technique in patients
on multiple po medications and/or who have poorer health when
prescribing adrenergic acting medications, i.e., the beta-blockers
and the alpha adrenergic receptor agonists.)
Brimonidine reduces IOP by approximately 20 to 25%. Because
of its rapid onset of action, it can be useful in treating
acute rises in IOP, such as post-laser spikes and angle closure.
Its most commonly-discussed systemic side effects are dry mouth
and fatigue. Uveitis was reported in the September 2000 American
Journal of Ophthalmology to be a potential late side effect,
so be aware of this association. This granulomatous uveitis
was seen after about one year of brimonidine therapy, and subsided
upon cessation of the drug.
Dr. Louis Pasquale, quoted earlier in this chapter, made another
interesting observation in the March/April 2002 issue of Vision
and Aging: “The systemic side effects of brimonidine don’t
get a lot of attention. A strikingly high number of patients
have a great deal of central nervous system-type side effects
with this drug, increasing headache, fatigue, inability to
sleep at night, dry eye and mouth.”
|